Wednesday, January, 22,2025

Ex-SCBA chief rebuts Kapil Sibal's impeachment motion against Allahabad HC judge

New Delhi: Amid the controversy over alleged hate speech by an Allahabad High Court judge Justice Shekhar Kumar Yadav, senior advocate and former Supreme Court Bar Association (SCBA) president Adish C Aggarwal on Friday defended the judge, saying judges, like all citizens, have the right to freedom of expression.
His remarks came after Rajya Sabha MP and SCBA President Kapil Sibal earlier today submitted an impeachment motion against Justice Shekhar Kumar Yadav.
Aggarwala said that while judges must recuse themselves from cases where they have expressed an opinion, the act of a judge speaking on an issue does not, in itself, warrant impeachment.
Aggarwala acknowledged that Justice Yadav's public speech could have been avoided but stressed that it does not justify initiating impeachment proceedings against him.
"I believe this impeachment motion is a calculated move to intimidate the judiciary, and in fact, it threatens the very independence of the judicial system," Aggarwala said.
Aggarwala pointed out that Kapil Sibal is fully aware that such an impeachment motion is unlikely to succeed, as it requires a two-thirds majority in both Houses of Parliament--something that is currently not feasible in the prevailing political climate.
Kapil Sibal had earlier stated, "We have given a notice to the Rajya Sabha Secretary General to impeach Allahabad High Court Judge Justice Shekhar Kumar Yadav. He made an inflammatory speech on December 9 at the High Court premises. We believe he no longer has the right to hold his position and should be removed. This is not a political issue, but an issue of protecting the Constitution and the independence of the judiciary."
Sibal also urged Prime Minister Modi, Union Home Minister Amit Shah, and leaders of the ruling party to support the motion, claiming that the Supreme Court should order the removal of Justice Yadav and bar him from any further work until a decision is made.
Aggarwala, however, firmly disagreed with the motion, reinforcing that the integrity and independence of the judiciary must be preserved and that the process of impeachment should not be misused for political purposes.

  Share on

Related News

visit e-papers

Daily Astro

image

Aries

Today brings opportunities for growth, but you'll need to stay focused. Trust your instincts to navigate challenges.

image

Pisces

Your intuition will guide you. Trust your feelings and explore creative outlets for peace of mind.

image

Aquarius

Innovation is your theme today. Explore unconventional ideas to solve lingering problems.

image

Capricorn

Hard work pays off today. Your dedication and discipline will lead to well-deserved recognition.

image

Sagittarius

Adventure is calling! Embrace new opportunities, but keep a balanced approach to risks.

image

Scorpio

Your determination will be unmatched. Dive deep into tasks, but don't forget to take breaks to recharge.

image

Libra

Harmony in relationships is your priority. Compromise and understanding will strengthen your bonds.

image

Virgo

Focus on organization and details. A well-planned day will lead to productive results and personal satisfaction.

image

Leo

Leadership will come naturally. Take charge of situations but remain humble for the best outcomes.

image

Cancer

Emotional balance is key today. Spend quality time with loved ones to find comfort and clarity.

image

Gemini

Today is perfect for networking and sharing ideas. Your adaptability will help you tackle unexpected changes with ease.

image

Taurus

Patience will be your strength today. Financial matters might need attention, so think twice before making big decisions.